Pick Your All-American Which of These Would You Want Most to be a Duck?

[30Duck]

I'm sure any of these players would make a great Duck. My first thought was our old buddy, Jeremiah Smith. But would he help the most?

 

PFF’s Preseason 2025 All-American Team: Cade Klubnik, Jeremiah Smith and more 

WWW.PFF.COM

---

Max Chadwick reveals PFF’s Preseason 2025 All-American Team, which includes Cade Klubnik, Jeremiah Smith and more.

 

[Jon Joseph]

 

I'd love to see Caleb Downs at safety along with Thieneman. 

 

That's a heavy dose of SEC OL guys along with Fano from Utah. Possible sneaky good opening game when the Utes play UCLA in Pasadena. 

 

TE from Vandy? A&M guys are always here, and the Aggies lose four games every season. 

 

I'm not sure that Klubnik is the best QB in South Carolina. LaNorris Sellers at USC(e) is a baller and took down the Tigers and Klubnik in Clemson last season.

 

In Clemson's opener vs. LSU, LSU QB Nussmeir could outplay Klubnik. But can Kelly win an opening game? Where was Clemson DL Woods last season? The Clemson D gave up a lot of big plays. Clemson could go 10-2 and win the ACC with bookend SEC losses. 

 

Including Special teams, 12 players from the SEC and 6 from the B1G are on the list. The B1G was not dominated by the SEC in the first round of the 2024 NFL draft and more than acquitted itself vs. the SEC in the postseason.

 

I think there are players on the Georgia team that Kirby would not trade for the Texas and the A&M guys.

 

Thanks for the post.

 

 

OK, please pass me a Dixie Cup. 

 

 

[30Duck]

On 5/29/2025 at 5:42 PM, Jon Joseph said:

I'd love to see Caleb Downs at safety along with Thieneman. 

I definitely like this and give me the Edge from USC(e), Stewart. it was very satisfying to not see the SEC dominating the Draft, after the B1G has won the Natty two years in a row, and the SEC wasn't even in either game.